Wednesday, March 5, 2008

It's a Secret to Everybody

Nobody wants to know who dies in their favorite story or what the twist is at the end of the summer blockbuster if they haven't gotten around to reading/watching it yet. Along the same lines, I've found that there are people who don't like to be told what to do in a game because they believe "figuring it out" is half the fun. This pet peeve for gamers goes as far as some players skipping tutorials, and snapping at those who offer advise (or at least ignoring them). Certainly in the majority of puzzle games "figuring it out" is all of the fun, and giving the player puzzle solutions destroys the gameplay experience for them. However, for all of the genres based on action, mechanics, and skill, being told how to do something still leaves the player with the challenging task of executing the action.



Unlike other mediums, games sustain an interactive relationship with the player(s). Even the most simple games are quite complex when you think about it. Some games are quite deep and complex that there is no way for the developers to include a tutorial for everything. There are some techniques and moves in games that the developers didn't even know about when they made the game. This evolutionary quality of gameplay is known as emergence. Like a biological mutation that stems from a single offspring in a given generation, when a game is released, the hundreds of thousands or millions of players are all working the game over in countless ways. And when one person finds out you can hop over the walls in Wario's Stadium twice to get an overall race time of 21 seconds, or when you can slide gracefully along the floor in Super Smash Brothers Melee by air dodging diagonally downward, the internet does a remarkable job of getting this information to the world. Like a virus or beneficial mutation, these "secrets to everybody" spread.

Ignoring everything the developers is unaware of, what about the things they deliberately programmed in? Masahiro Sakurai has maintained his personal blog for Super Smash Brothers BRAWL since last summer. He has covered everything from items, characters, techniques, and stages for his game. Yet, even though he has revealed specific ways to use specific moves with specific characters, he admits himself that he doesn't want to get too technical. It is obvious that this particular game reaches a wide audience some of which wouldn't be interested in the technical side of games. However, the game is rated T for teen. I feel that thirteen-year-olds are old enough to handle technical information. And furthermore, what's the harm for sneaking in a few lines of it anyway.

"I’ll try not to get too technical with things, but just know that there are lots of small tricks like these for you to play around with." ~Sakurai

At the end of the day, games are complex computerized machines that have a wonderful coating of graphics filled with familiar forms to bridge the gap of communication between the bit world of computers and the human world of the real. In other words, games are high tech and we shouldn't be afraid to be more explicit when talking about them and teaching the player how to play.



The best example I have of a game that teaches how it works is Team Fortress 2. This game features a commentary mode where players can run around the multiplayer maps activating commentary audio files from the developers. These audio blurbs talk about everything from lighting and shadows, character classes, the forms that fit their functions, level lay out, and more invisible things like how the respawning system works and why they took out elements from the previous game in the series. Not only was this information highly informative, but it was entertaining, it helped to reduced the high amount of information that is needed to begin playing the game, and I was still in complete control over what I wanted to listen to. If I were a gamer that didn't like technical talk, I could simply avoid listening to those commentary files. As a game designer, this kind of commentary is gold. Just hearing the developers talk about the tactics and strategies they designed into the game helped me organize the concepts in my own mind. My sister, after hearing the commentary, began playing better and smarter in Call of Duty 4. Though the games are both FPSs, they are very different. Regardless, from listening to the commentary she now has a much clearer concept of high-ground and low-ground and their advantages, which keeps her alive longer in COD4.

Just coming out straight and telling the player how to play can't be a bad thing when you don't force the player through the information. Even the "Try This" videos in Donkey Kong Jungle Beat do wonders for giving the player just enough inspiration and curiosity to expand the way they play the game.

If you're developing a game out there, don't be like that mean kid who, when he finally gives you a turn to play the game, doesn't tell you any of the controls and proceeds to immediately beat you down. And at the same time, don't be like the hard cover strategy guide that turns a game into a reading comprehension exercise.

Find the balance. Find the way to make your game a secret to everybody.

GuitaRPG: Fitting Form to Function

These final few days before Brawl hits, I've been deep in thought devising the visual style for GuitaRPG. Unlike Neo*RPG where I ripped the majority of the sprites from a Geometry Wars clone on the PC, I plan on hand illustrating all the art (or at least getting some help doing the artwork). The process has been a slow one because I have to pick a style that I can easily produce a lot of images in, while also keeping in mind that the form of the objects in the game must serve their function. Even from what little conceptually I have thought through of GuitaRPG's core gameplay, I know I want to put a strong emphasis on color. Because the buttons on the Guitar Hero Guitar controller are color coded, I'll be adapting this color scheme to develope a universal color code that the game will follow. In order to accentuate this color code, I plan on illustrating GuitaRPG with solid shapes that create contrast with simple areas of black and white (and to a lesser extent grey and even brown).

As I work on some preliminary images, feel free to visit my Deviant art page.

To conclude, I'll provide examples of other art styles that I'm drawing inspiration from. Notice the differences in how detail is created. Textures. Layered flat colors/shapes. Fine pen work.









~stay tuned

Saturday, March 1, 2008

Layton and the Clean Bill of Success

Professor Layton and the Curious Village is a perfect example of a hyper clean game that is completely devoted and focused on two things. The first is the game's primary function.



1) Puzzles puzzles and more puzzles
  • Everything is a puzzle; challenges, the town, your hotel room, paintings, inventions, scenarios, and the story. There is something curious about everything and it's your job to get to the bottom of it.
  • Every character knows about, is concerned with, and gives away puzzles as a means of social exchange.
  • Solving puzzles is the primary function of Professor Layton, but it goes beyond that. Solving puzzles is a vague mechanic at best, which, in the game, can involve everything from talking to specific characters, going to specific locations, arranging items in your hotel room, reassembling a painting from scraps, drawing lines, pointing out the culprit, to writing in words on the touch screen. The game oscillates between all these mechanics to keep things fresh. At the same time, because the game changes so frequently to the context of the scenario the player finds him/herself in, the function of solving puzzles fits the player into the role analogous to Layton and Luke, his apprentice. Like in any role playing game or situation, a significant emphasis is put on.....
2) The story
  • As a pseudo detective, the player will be piecing together mysteries, and cracking puzzles that, in this zany world, all come together and fit nicely within the conceit of the game.
  • At first the towns people's staunch devotion to puzzles may seem comically forced even within the context of a game. But, rest assured, everything serves a simple and focused purposed that is nestled deep within the games story. I won't spoil the game for anyone.

Everything else about the game is ultra streamlined.
  • menus navigation
    • touch screen based
    • large images
  • maps
    • conveniently displayed on the top screen
  • HUD
    • Displayed cleanly on the top screen including....
    • A short phrase that tells you where your next objective is
    • A score display of how many puzzles you've solved
    • What area of the top you're currently at
  • traveling around town
    • Just tap the shoe icon and an arrow will appear indicating the possible directions you can venture to.
    • You can't get lost when you can't explore outside of limited areas.
  • talking and interacting with people
    • If you see a person, tap them on the touch screen to start a conversation. It's as simple as that
  • solving puzzles
    • Each puzzle has a number and a difficultly level
    • Each puzzle has 3 hints that can be purchased with hint coins if you need help

Keep Layton in mind when you're trying to design clean games (or parts of games). Layton has certainly given me the needed boost in creative possibilities as I design GuitaRPG. I hope to be able to share some of the details shortly.