Saturday, March 15, 2008

Third Impressions: Lots of Lists

Some are still unconvinced. For whatever reason, when they look at Brawl they can't help but count up all the things that have been removed to support the argument that Brawl is less deep or even dumbed down than its predecessor. As game designers, or people who think like designers, we know that it is not the number of features or options that can change a game significantly, but what function these features have in shaping how the game is played.



A friend of mine submitted a list of commonly viewed elements that have supposedly been removed for the worse in Brawl. I would like to take this time to clarify how these options functioned in Melee, perhaps why they were removed from Brawl, and what Brawl has instead. That's right, I'm making a list too.

No L-Canceling
  • As I have said before, in Brawl air A attacks have the "l-cancel" built right into the moves. Not only is this better for online play, but for casuals and pros alike. The game inputs are less manic now, which reduces the stress of high speed play. If you're upset that you don't have to hit a button to achieve such levels of play, then I suggest letting this one go. If you wanted online play, then this is the first thing that had to get the boot. In the end, the game still plays like we can L-cancel, so what is there to complain about?
No Wavedashing
  • There is wave dashing in Brawl, or maybe it's more aptly described as wave sliding. It works the same way too: simply air dodge diagonally into the ground and you'll slide a little. Of course, this isn't what most would consider a wavedash. So in effect, the ability to scoot around a playing field in short bursts while facing the same direction is apparently gone. But this is a good thing. Not only did wave dashing look unnatural, but it significantly increased the level of non commitment between players. At any moment when walking or dashing, the play could quickly slide back and away from their opponent. This often ended up dragging matches out as both players are tried to get close but not too close. Wave sliding had other uses as well. Falco worked wonders with it, his dash, and down air.
  • This is not to mention that wave dashing also increased the speed of moving onto and off of platforms. But once again, this unnatural movement and characters speed stretched the game in strange directions. Have you ever seen a Gannondorf perfectly wave dash on and off of the platforms on Yoshi's Story. It is so fast, it's silly. Brawl has plenty of new defensive and offensive options that help with speed and spacing that don't compromise the visual form of the game. If you're looking for the function of wave dashing, then keep reading.
No Crouch Cancel
  • Not only do I generally dislike cancels in game design (especially fighters), I really dislike crouch canceling. Because of this extremely easy to execute counter, many moves at many percentages when successfully landed can put the attacker at high levels of risk. Peach, Samus, and Marth could do very effective counters just by holding down and then smashing. I've even crouch-canceled-countered a few good hits as Kirby when at 130%. That's not right. If anyone is upset about losing this, then they need to wake up and smell the function (sorry guys, had to say it). By taking out crouch canceling, we now have access to more moves at more percentages than in Melee. And if you're the kind of player that is still upset that the L-canceling is automatic and thus "dumbing down" the game, consider this: crouch canceling and down smashing was one of the easiest and most effective counters in Melee. Many jokes were made about it in fact. Just hold down and repeatedly hit the c-stick down for the win.
No Light Shielding
  • I, KrazyKirbyKid, am the biggest proponent for light shielding in Melee. After all, I invented the Marth trick and several other advanced techniques involving light shields. However, light shielding wasn't balanced correctly in Melee. The drawback for having a bigger shield was supposed to be a more brittle shield. Using a light shield should result in a greater opportunity for the opponent to break your shield. However, light shields weren't very weak compared to the heavy shields. What this does functionally is it gives the player more shield for free. If you're feet or head are poking out of your shield, just light shield and everything will work out. Sure, you'll slide around a little more, and you won't be able to shield grab, but who needs those things when you can jump out of shield and wave slide, jump and attack, or do a side dodge. The new shields in Brawl not only fade much more quickly, but they make poking feet and heads more viable because these areas can't be covered up so easily. Brawl has more defensive options that Melee, so a less effective shield is a good thing to prevent an overly defensive turtling game.
No Dash Dancing
  • Dash dancing is just like wave sliding: rapid repeated inputs for spacing that add to the non commitment style of play that ultimately drags out matches and stretches the games ability. In Brawl we still have up smash out of dash, pivot grabs, and pivot smashes. If you're the kind of player who wants to quickly stay just out of range of your opponent, then use the new features Brawl has. And if you missed dance dancing that much, you can still do little ones in place. Go ahead, increase the chances of tripping.
No Directional Air Dodging
  • Air dodging as been significantly altered. You can do it multiple times, there's no lag for landing on the ground, and it goes with the player's momentum. Because of the former two attributes the last one had to follow. Not only is it better for online play because the computer can track the players position using havok and physics calculations, but it also allows the non air-dodging players to counter this new and highly versatile approach. If you could dodge in any direction in addition to having no lag when landing, then the player would have too many ways to trick up their approach making this move highly unbalanced. Now, even when you airdodge, everyone knows where you're going to be/land because you're still affected by the same gravity that you were subject to before. It's new. It's genius. And it's balanced. No complaining.
No Ledge Games
  • This one is the most rash. I believe this statement was created in response to how most characters will "zip" or "snap" to the ledge making the end of their recovery extremely safe. Well, all characters don't zip to the edge. Kirby and Dedede are just two examples of characters that don't zip to the edge coming up with their recovery moves. Though most characters do have this zip ability, it is more complex than that. The characters that can zip only do so when facing the edge and moving towards it. This means if they're recovering while moving away from the ledge (as in from underneath the stage), or trying to take advantage of how characters can now grab the edge while falling backwards, you can hit them away or spike them like we always have. What this new zip has prevented is characters dominating the ledge because they've found one attack that wins in the majority of situations while never leaving the ledge. I'm looking at your Marth, Peach, Falco, and Fox. I'm not sure where the complains are coming from on this one anyway. Fox, Falco, Mario, Peach, and other characters had magical zips when sweet spotting in Melee. We dealt with it then and moved on. If you're upset that because most characters can do it instead of the few, the overpowered, the high tiers, then get over it.
  • Furthermore, you can still grab the ledge and hold on to it to make the opponent fall to their doom when recovering. Also, you can roll up from the ledge preventing the opponent from grabbing it if you're good enough. It just take more skill this time. Isn't that what everyone wanted, more skillful tactics? Many of the options from Melee are still in Brawl. The only difference is, one tactic doesn't rule all forcing players to be aware of more things and mix it up. Additionally, the game has been out a week. Chill and and give it some time.
Freedom to Tether Walls
  • This freedom from Melee was too good especially for Samus. She could bomb jump to recover, up B with high priority and a sweet spot, walk kick for invincibility and height, and to top it top it all off, she could tether the walls for even more versatility. Playing against Huggs was a nightmare. I locked out option after option trying to knock that guy out, and when I did out play him, Kirby's attacks were so weak, I would have to do it all over again many times. In other words, this freedom was an unbalanced special ability that only 3 characters had in Melee. Now, in Brawl, tether recovering characters are in a class of their own. To help balance this recovery method, they auto aim for the ledge. If there's someone there, they fall. If not, they can latch on the the ledge from amazing distances away. Taking out the freedom to tether any wall anywhere balances the game.

As I have mentioned several times, Brawl is built for balance. Perhaps the people who are most upset about Brawl at this point played a little to many high tier characters for a bit too long. Fox. Shiek. Marth. Falco. Peach. Captain Falcon. High tier lists like that is one list I can live without.

Friday, March 14, 2008

Second Impressions: Big Differences

Brawl is already deeper than Melee, and there's nothing Melee can do about it. It seems hard to believe that in about a week I can come to this decision. But remember, because I've been following Brawls design paths for so long, it's as if I've been playing Brawl for months.



For the most part the game plays and feels as lot like Melee, that is to say it's still smash. Right off the bat, Brawl is a lot cleaner. The clutter in Melee stemmed from from a high game speed, invincible frames, and other invisible aspects of the gameplay (like L-cancels). All of those areas have been addressed. Upon first seeing Brawl in motion, I thought the game speed was dramatically reduced. Now, though the air fall speed has been decreased making all the characters appear to be "floaty," the game speed is actually just as fast or (could it be) faster. Sakurai commented long before that Brawl has a new air game. And true to his word, the aerial battles and ballets are nothing short that exhilarating. Because how much a player can DI away from attacks and the stun time from attacks has been reduced, more attacks and dodges can fit in a single aerial encounter than ever before. Also, footstool jumping allows both players to extend their air time/options by jumping off of each other. This new, non-aggressive way to interact in the air essentially extends part of the "ground" game into the skies. And with each option flows a triangle of balance that are tied seamlessly into the greater flow of the battle. And that's just removing the clutter.

I personally believe that Melee wasn't balanced at all. It's not that it was unbalanced, I believe the developers didn't concern themselves with balancing the characters at all. This time around, Sakurai has crafted each character with his own hands (literally [kind of]) putting a significant amount of time and focus on balance. If a character has a really good kill move, there are drawbacks. They might not have many kill moves, it might not have a lot of range, they might only have kill moves that kill horizontally or vertically which in turn shapes how they approach their enemies. If a character is really fast, they're generally weak forcing them to chase down their opponents repeatedly for kills. I've already noted a variety of ways really strong moves and characters have drawbacks designed right in. Beyond this level of balance, Stale-move negation keeps players using a variety of moves because the effectiveness (damage and knock back) of each move will weaken dramatically if used in succession.

What's even more exciting about having to use a variety of moves to round out one's game is, every move is effective in Brawl. From the neutral a punches to the smallest low tilts, every move can be used. In Melee, crouch canceling and L-canceling put a lot of emphasis on the air game while greatly reducing the effectiveness of the ground game. Tilts couldn't typically be used against a crouch canceling ready to down smash opponent. Melee's design essentially took away one's ground moves and turn them into a shffling air attacking junkie. But with Brawl, there's no L-canceling or crouch canceling, plus the range of DI from attacks have been tailored for each attack. This means you can't DI all my attacks 45 degress up all the time. Now, when I forward tilt you, you go forward. Now when I low tilt you, you slide out and maybe even trip up. Furthermore, there were many moves in Melee that became increasingly ineffective when used on opponents of higher and higher damage percentages. After all, when the move doesn't do a lot of damage, it doesn't kill, and the opponent keeps DIing it up and away, then it only serves to stall the game out. In other words, in Brawl attacks just work.

Many have cried about the loss of their beloved technique L-canceling. I'm not sure why they're so upset. The air A moves in Brawl auto-cancel, which basically means they cancel themselves. In reality, this is no cancel at all, but the speed at which some moves can finish with their animation is just like L-canceling. Back in Smash64, L-canceling canceled all the lag. In Melee, it cuts the lag in half. I believe this was an attempt for Melee to keep some of the moves relatively slow even when l-canceling, like Link's down air. Brawl does the same thing while reducing the need to slap a button upon landing. Most very strong moves take time to recover, while most quick weak moves take no time at all. Brawl is built this way to keep gameplay smooth, focused, and uncluttered without manic button presses. Also, there's no way to successfully have Melee's L-canceling with online play. The packets of information that would have to be sent as your character hits the ground and l-cancels could easily get lost in the web, not to mention the timing for doing so would be inconsistent depending on the connection.

The new auto canceling air moves makes the air a wonderful place to be. However, shield grabbing is still in effect. What's new with Brawl though is that attacks can not only stun shields but make the opponent slide back consistently. When this happens the opponent is usually too far away to grab you. The best way to send your opponent sliding back is with smash attacks. In Melee, smash attacks could be shield grabbed fairly easily. But now, a greater emphasis is placed on smashing.

Perfect Shielding is the new way to defend yourself and turn the tables on your opponents. After successfully power shielding in Melee, dropping the shield and retaliating took too long to be viable. Furthermore, because the speed of the game was so high because of L-canceling, the opponent could pour on the pressure without fear. Additionally, because the timing window for a power shield was just frames before an attack hits you (a great enough risk as it is), the critical moment to strike would be gone in a flash. In Brawl, the timing is easier not only because shielding is on a button instead of a gamecube trigger, but also because the timing has a bigger window, player can better prepare for the counter attack. To counter a perfect shield, multi hitting attacks or rapidly hitting attacks fit neatly into the small gap of time the opponents have to retaliate. This gives more importance to the use of the neutral A attacks.

To mix up opponents who perfect shield a lot, the new momentum based air dodge has virtually no lag when the character hits the ground. This makes it possible to fly through or behind an opponent and find an opening instantly with an attack. However, to counter this approach, up tilts and up smashes now cover a little area in front and behind all characters, so falling opponents can't easily drop right through them and score free hits.

Wrap it all together and you have an amazing new game that exceeds Melee by many times. But wait, there's more. Brawl has a 10 frame buffer window between attacks. What this means is, if you want to go from one move/attack directly into another move/attack as soon as possible, at the last 10 frames of first move/attack, if you input the next command, the character will start it as soon as the first move is over. This means, to play a character cleanly, quickly, and tightly you don't have to sit down and memorize a book of frame data. Now you can feel out your character's lag and focus more on having fun. Anything that takes the chore out of a game and keeps players playing is a better design choice.

If anyone is upset that Brawl has this wonderful feature, then they can go play another game. In a world of well designed games and Smash, Brawl is king. And that's the biggest difference you need to know.

Thursday, March 13, 2008

First Impressions: Brawl

So what do I think of Brawl? After years of speculation, after writing hundreds of pages about the improvements that needed to be made from Melee, after making a list of my predictions, after studying hours of footage on youtube, what do I really think of this game now that I've finally gotten my hands on it. Well, I haven't played it for too long. I'm only fifty-three hours into Brawl and it's been five days since its release. Jokes aside, I've barely scratched the surface of this game. Though this phrase gets tossed around often, I assure you that I'm gauging my judgments based on how deep Melee is. After all, I haven't even played all the characters, levels, or modes yet.



Needless to say the game is massive, and I am more than immensely pleased with Brawl. Playing Brawl puts me in a strange state. It feels like I've played the game before. After picking apart melee by writing hundreds of pages worth in articles delineating Sakurai's personal style, his design choices, and using this information to project what Brawl would be like, now it feels like I've been playing Brawl for years. As it turns out, 34/50 of my predictions about various aspects of the game were actually implemented into Brawl.

When I play, all I see is the result of a true 3rd generation game that has refined and innovated every step of the way. Every characters, every move, and every animation clicks into place. Compared to Brawl, Melee isn't a very well designed game. There were so many poorly designed elements that we simply put up with and have gotten used to with Melee. As a game designer myself, I know the design principles behind the changes in Brawl are essential for a good game. By taking out invisible elements of the game, and cancels like crouch canceling and l-canceling, more about how the game is played is communicated through its visuals. Furthermore, by adding new types of hits like tripping and footstool jumping, and by carefully balancing each character, Brawl is deeper than any other smash.

Though it may be too early to make such a bold statement, what we do know about Brawl at this point certainly leads one in that positive direction. Some have said that options have been taken away in Brawl, while other complain about the design choices that have made Brawl more casual friendly. These stances are short sighted. And if you really think about it, crouch canceling and L-canceling took away far more options than Brawl ever could. Without a significant amount of stale move negation, Shffling a few moves per character became the norm in Melee. In Brawl, each move is more important in the overall options and flow of a players strategy. Additionally, each move in Brawl works. The damage curves, knock back, and lag times have been adjusted for every move making them viable in multitudinous situations in a dynamically shifting way.

Brawl is so good it's hard to believe. I'll have more impressions later going over many things in detail and even providing some commentary that isn't too positive. It's Brawl week now, and after secretly playing Brawl for months, it was well worth the wait.